Tuesday, 11 November 2014

Should ITTF Legalise Boosting?

One of the hottest debates in table tennis is the moral argument of whether or not to boost. I personally don't boost and choose not to purely because it is the rule of the sport that boosting is not legal. In saying that I believe that boosting should be made legal for a few very simple reasons.



The New Ball

The new ball is designed to slow the game down, we all know that rubber manufacturers around the world are already doing their absolute best to combat the reduction in speed and spin by turning out generations of rubbers which are spinner and faster than ever before. We love this sport because of speed, we love it because of spin, so why reduce both? Why not allow booster so we can balance out longer rallies and still great speed, spin and control? We could avoid the frustrations of changing technique as much and having to deal with everything lagging. Of course this is not so important and is by no means the main reason why I think boosting should be legalised.

It's Not Harmful

Speed glue was originally banned because of it's VOC content which was deemed to be harmful, some clever individual decided to consume come of it for reasons unknown to any intelligent human being. Most boosters on the other hand are VOC free, hence why they are undetectable by the ITTF in racket testing. If they are not harmful then there is no real reason to ban them in that aspect.

It Creates An Unfair Playing Field

This is the ultimate reason why boosting should be legalised. Face it, the ITTF can't detect boosters and for that reason they are also unable to police it. They are wasting time and resources to try and crack down on something unimportant. They want people to stop boosting out of fairness for those who follow the rules. Easier solution. Legalise boosting. This way the people who want to follow the rules, like me, are not disadvantaged against people who don't care about the rule and boost. It is difficult to play against a Chinese player with a freshly boosted bat when you are back in the dinosaur ages with your slower water based glued rubbers. They have an uncanny ability to make your loops look like trash. Granted a good player will be able to do this anyway, but sometimes you can see quite clearly how boosted rubber is giving them the advantage in the game.

Why Do I Care About the Rule?

You might say, well if you think the rule against boosting is so unfair and since ITTF can't detect it then why don't you just join the masses and boost anyway? Well in my opinion rules are rules and I like to follow them and so do many others. This rule, as stupid as it is, is in place regardless and so I follow it.

So what is your opinion? Should boosters be legalised, is the rule sane or stupid? Are boosters just illegal so we have to constantly buy the latest upgraded rubber constantly as we had to with the new tensor rubbers to combat speed glue illegality and again now we need new rubber to combat the new ball?

Opinions are awesome, give me yours! :)

7 comments:

  1. The ITTF is killing table tennis as we know it

    Soon enough all we'll be restricted to short pips, a 44mm ball, a higher net and high toss serves for "viewing pleasure"

    ReplyDelete
  2. My understanding is that boosting is only illegal if it's done by the user after they've bought a rubber. Manufacturers can pretty much do what they like prior to shipping a product? If this is the case why are they not selling preboosted rubbers or offering boosting at different levels as a premium service? Surely that would satisfy all parties legally. It just wouldn't cover those who like to boost old rubbers to squeeze a few more matches out of them.

    ReplyDelete
  3. People are animal that refuse for changes. Thus, when there is new thing or new rule come out, most people would object rather than simply accept it. I would think it should be given a try for booster, and for sure first rule rolling out won't be perfect as it is also on trial basis. The ITTF can then fine tune the rule to make it acceptable by all players. This is just what I think.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The ITTF has done pretty much nothing about all the rampant boosting, everywhere from the lowest levels to the highest levels. Even if everything they have tried up until now (which is still very, very little) was a legitimate effort, it has done nothing.

    I think that the ITTF just needs to do SOMETHING, because the ITTF right now is not doing anything for the sport. The ITTF managed to eradicate several legitimate styles of play by banning long pimples and changing the ball a couple times, but they still somehow cannot stop players from boosting their rubbers or hiding the contact of their serve.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I totally agree with the article, except the comment of Chinese players as on the ITTF Pro Tour there are not so many left of any country not using booster.

    ReplyDelete